We had a great party with 60-70 folks attending. The blind tasting I set up attracted about 25-30 participants and the results were very interesting. I asked everyone to rate five wines from their favorite to least favorite. My '07 Zin was clearly the most controversial wine in the lineup. While five people rated it their favorite, nine people thought just the opposite! One fellow kept commenting on how much he hated it! lol
I guess such differing opinions are likely when I chose to serve a non-finished barrel sample alongside some zins from some of the best winemakers in California like Mike Officer and Ed Kurtzman. So, while it was a fun tasting, I'm not sure I gained any valuable information from the experiment. There didn't appear to be any clear-cut favorite with some people liking the $11 Cline Zin more than the Carlisle (a 93 point Parker wine). Others preferred a Maryland zin that I personally didn't care for at all.
All in all, we had a great time and that's I all I was really hoping for.
The return
9 years ago